Sophie T's Pizza

Located in the heart of Nantucket, Sophie T's Pizza brings a delightful slice of comfort food to both locals and visitors craving authentic, satisfying pizza and fast food fare. This cozy pizza spot at 7 Dave St is popular for its generous toppings, rich sauces, and perfectly melted cheese that come together in every handcrafted pie. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or settling in for a casual meal with friends, Sophie T’s warm and welcoming atmosphere invites you to savor every bite.

The menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, but it's the Pepperoni Garlic and Xtra Cheese Pizza that truly shines with its balance of zesty pepperoni, fragrant garlic, and a blanket of gooey cheese that makes each slice irresistible. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the Meatball Parmigiana Sub offers a comforting blend of juicy meatballs, savory sauce, and melted cheese enveloped in fresh bread — a real crowd-pleaser as praised by regulars.

Classic pizza lovers can indulge in perfectly crafted Cheese and Pepperoni pizzas available in both small (12") and large (18") sizes, each slice boasting a soft, doughy crust and topped with just the right amount of sauce and cheese to satisfy any craving. For those who like a bit more adventure, the Bacon Chicken Pizza and Sausage and Peppers pizza slices deliver bold, savory flavors that burst with every bite. The opportunity to build your own pizza makes it easy to customize exactly what you want, from the freshest ingredients to your preferred crust size.

Beyond pizza, Sophie T's menu includes delicious sides and salads like the fresh Caesar salad and surprisingly tasty quesadilla, offering great balance to any meal. The Porchetta and Arugula options add a unique twist that speaks to the restaurant’s dedication to variety and quality. It’s clear from the big smiles and repeat visits that Sophie T’s serves food that not only satisfies hunger but also warms the heart.

Customers rave about the consistent quality and flavor. Jeffrey Kaplan called it "a find," highlighting the flavorful Meatball Parm that's rich with sauce and cheese, a testament to Sophie T’s commitment to generous, balance-packed dishes. Another guest, Troy Giesselman, applauds the pizza for standing out from the usual New York style with its “extremely good pies” and even praises the accompanying lasagna as “best in class.” While some note that the crust leans soft and doughy rather than thin and crisp, this trait adds a comforting, homemade appeal that feels like a warm embrace at the end of a Nantucket day.

Whether grabbing a slice solo, ordering multiple pizzas for family and friends, or enjoying a casual meal watching the news on TV, Sophie T’s Pizza delivers a genuine experience full of hearty flavor and unpretentious charm. With friendly service and an inviting neighborhood vibe, it’s no wonder Sophie T's has earned a special place in the Nantucket community and the hearts of pizza lovers alike.